Monte Carlo simulation explained simply: why a fixed return leads you astray
A projection with a 5% annual return says: your money will easily last. A simulation with the same assumptions says: in almost one case in three, it runs out early. Both calculate correctly. Only one shows you what really matters.
The problem with the average return
Most calculators on the internet and many advisory meetings work with a fixed return. You enter an amount, choose 5 or 6% a year and see a smooth curve that rises steadily. It looks precise. But it is an assumption that will never come true.
Stock markets do not deliver 5% a year. They deliver +25% one year, then −18%, then +9%, then +31%. Over the long run, the average may come out at a similar figure. But what matters for your wealth is the order in which these years arrive, especially when you are withdrawing money. The keyword: sequence-of-returns risk.
A worked example
Let’s assume you retire with €500,000 and withdraw €20,000 in the first year, then 2% more every year to offset inflation. The portfolio consists of 80% broadly diversified equity ETFs and 20% money market.
The classic projection with a fixed 5% a year shows: after 30 years, around €487,000 is left. The wealth remains almost untouched. All good.
The Monte Carlo simulation with realistic fluctuations, taxes and the same withdrawals paints a different picture:
| Result after 30 years | Value |
|---|---|
| Money lasts 30 years | in 72 of 100 scenarios |
| Wealth in the middle scenario (median) | around €412,000 |
| Wealth in the worst 10% of scenarios | €0, the money runs out early |
The middle scenario looks similar to the projection. But in a good quarter of cases, the money does not last. These are exactly the cases a fixed return hides. And they are exactly the ones you want to protect yourself against.
How a Monte Carlo simulation works
The name comes from the casino in Monaco, because the method works with chance. Instead of a single future, the simulation calculates thousands of possible futures:
- Set assumptions: expected return and volatility for each asset class, inflation, taxes, withdrawals, pension and other inflows.
- Roll the dice for a year: For each year, the simulation draws a random return that fits the assumptions. Sometimes +20%, sometimes −15%, mostly something in between.
- Calculate one life path: Year by year, returns, taxes, withdrawals and inflows are booked, up to the end of the planning period.
- Repeat thousands of times: The whole thing runs 10,000 or 20,000 times, each time with a different sequence of good and bad years.
- Evaluate: At the end, the simulation counts in how many runs the money lasted and shows the range of outcomes.
Reading the results correctly
Three figures are enough to understand a simulation:
- Success rate: In how many scenarios does the money last until the end? Many planners aim for 85–95%. 100% usually means you could spend considerably more.
- Median: the middle result. Half of the scenarios end better, half worse. It is the realistic expected value, but not a promise.
- 10th percentile: the result that only the worst 10% of scenarios fall below. This is your stress test: could you cope with this too?
In a chart, this looks like a fan. In the middle is the median line, around it the band from the 10th to the 90th percentile. The wider the fan, the more uncertain the future.
What the simulation cannot do
A simulation is only as good as its assumptions. You should know three limits:
- Extreme events: Most models assume normally distributed returns. Real crashes are more severe and more frequent. A sound plan therefore works with cautious returns or additionally tests individual crisis scenarios.
- Assumptions about the future: No one knows the stock market return of the next 30 years. The simulation shows what can happen under the assumptions, not what will happen.
- Simplifications: Taxes, costs and expenses are applied as flat rates. In real life they are more irregular.
This does not speak against the method. It speaks for reading the results as a range and recalculating the plan regularly.
Conclusion: plan for the range, not for the average
A fixed return answers the question: “What happens if everything goes to plan?” A Monte Carlo simulation answers the more important question: “What happens if it doesn’t?” Anyone building wealth or wanting to live off it should know both answers. I show what this means for the well-known rule of thumb in The 4% rule recalculated for Germany.
Try it yourselfWill my money last? The free calculatorCalculate now →Simulation assumptions
- Starting capital €500,000, first withdrawal €20,000, then +2% per year
- 80% global equity ETFs: expected return 7% p.a., volatility 16% p.a.; 20% money market: 2.5% p.a.
- Tax: 26.375% flat capital gains tax incl. solidarity surcharge, 30% partial exemption, only on the gain portion of units sold
- 20,000 simulations, annual steps, normally distributed returns
- Comparison projection: fixed 5% p.a., without taxes
General information, not investment or tax advice. Simulations are based on assumptions; past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.