← All articles
Withdrawals & retirement

How much can I withdraw from my portfolio? The 4% rule recalculated for Germany

Withdraw 4% of your wealth in the first year, adjust the amount for inflation every year, and your money will last 30 years. That is the best-known rule of thumb in retirement planning. For investors in Germany, it is more of an upper limit than a safe value.

Christoph Urban · · 8 min read
3 %3.5 %4 %4.5 %

Where the 4% rule comes from

The rule goes back to US financial planner William Bengen. In 1994 he examined which withdrawal rate would have survived every 30-year retirement in American history. He based this on US stocks and US government bonds from 1926 onwards. His answer: around 4% in the first year, adjusted for inflation thereafter, with an equity share of 50 to 75%.

Four years later, three professors at Trinity University in Texas extended the analysis, known as the “Trinity Study”. They no longer asked only about the worst case, but about success rates. A portfolio of 50% stocks and 50% bonds with a 4% withdrawal lasted 30 years in around 95% of historical periods.

Important: Bengen did not recommend 4% as a target. He was looking for the upper limit that would never have failed in the past.

Why the rule does not apply one-to-one in Germany

Four differences suggest calculating more cautiously:

  1. US data is a stroke of luck. The US stock market was one of the strongest in the world in the 20th century. If you invest globally today, you should not automatically plan with the same return.
  2. Taxes. The studies ignore taxes. In Germany, when you sell equity ETFs you effectively pay around 18.5% on the gain portion. Your withdrawals have to cover that.
  3. Longer retirement. The rule applies to 30 years. If you stop at 55 and may live to 95, you need 40 years. Every extra decade noticeably lowers the safe withdrawal rate.
  4. Cautious expectations. Many analysts expect lower returns over the coming decades than the historical average. Morningstar, for example, in its December 2025 study, gives a safe starting rate of 3.9% for new retirees (30 years, 90% probability of success).

The 4% rule recalculated for Germany

I recalculated the rule with a Monte Carlo simulation: 20,000 possible market paths, German taxes, a portfolio of 80% global equity ETFs and 20% money market, withdrawals increased by 2% a year, no pension. The question: in how many cases does the money last?

Withdrawal rate in year oneMoney lasts 30 yearsMoney lasts 40 years
3.0%92%79%
3.5%83%66%
4.0%71%52%
4.5%59%39%

With cautious return expectations and taxes, 4% over 30 years is no longer a safe value. If you plan for 40 years and have no other income, you end up closer to 3% or below.

What this means in euros

Wealth3.0%3.5%4.0%
€500,000€15,000/year (€1,250/month)€17,500/year (€1,458/month)€20,000/year (€1,667/month)
€1,000,000€30,000/year (€2,500/month)€35,000/year (€2,917/month)€40,000/year (€3,333/month)
€1,500,000€45,000/year (€3,750/month)€52,500/year (€4,375/month)€60,000/year (€5,000/month)

All amounts are first-year withdrawals after capital gains tax. Health insurance and other deductions are not yet included.

Five levers for a higher withdrawal

The table shows the strictest case: no other income, a fixed withdrawal, nothing coming in. In real life there is almost always some room:

  • State pension: As soon as your pension starts, the portfolio has to carry less. If you stop working at 60 and receive a pension from 67, you can withdraw considerably more in the years before.
  • Flexible withdrawals: If you withdraw a little less in weak market years, you can spend more on average, with the same level of safety.
  • Money market buffer: Two to four years of withdrawals in a savings or money market account mean you do not have to sell shares in a crash.
  • Inheritances and inflows: An expected inheritance or a life insurance payout changes the calculation significantly. It belongs in the plan, but with caution.
  • Spending in old age: Many people spend less from their mid-70s, especially on travel and mobility. A planned reduction of 15–20% increases your room for manoeuvre early on.

Conclusion: 4% is the start of the calculation, not the result

The 4% rule is a good starting point for the conversation, but it is not a plan. For investors in Germany with taxes, a globally diversified portfolio and a long retirement, the safe starting rate without other income is more like 3 to 3.5%. With a pension, flexible withdrawals and a buffer, it can be considerably higher. How much higher depends on your numbers. I explain how the simulation behind it works in Monte Carlo simulation explained simply.

Try it yourselfWill my money last? The free calculatorCalculate now →
Simulation assumptions
  • 80% global equity ETFs: expected return 7% p.a., volatility 16% p.a.; 20% money market: 2.5% p.a.
  • First-year withdrawal as a percentage of starting wealth, then +2% per year
  • Tax: 26.375% incl. solidarity surcharge, 30% partial exemption, only on the gain portion of units sold
  • No pension, no inflows, no church tax, no fund costs beyond the return assumption
  • 20,000 simulations per cell, annual steps, normally distributed returns
Sources
Christoph UrbanI am an independent financial planner in Berlin, focusing on retirement planning. I bought my first share at the age of twelve, paid a lot for my lessons during the dot-com era and have been studying evidence-based investing for 15 years. Today I help my clients plan how to build wealth and provide for retirement, without selling any products. Before that, I spent more than 25 years in marketing, including at MTV, Fox, Deezer and Kleinanzeigen.

General information, not investment or tax advice. Simulations are based on assumptions; past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.